3 BD / 1 BA
NY 11746


Find foreclosed homes for sale up to 60% below market value on our foreclosure listings
Search 289 foreclosed homes in Bay Shore, NY with prices ranging from $10k to $1.44M! Our updated foreclosure listings include different types of cheap homes for sale like: 12 bank-owned foreclosures, 237 pre-foreclosures, 40 sheriff sales and 9 cheap homes for sale under $100k. Find 2 new foreclosures for sale in Bay Shore, NY added this month!.
Navigating the Bay Shore foreclosure market requires the right local knowledge. Use our resources below to understand the legal process and find the best investment opportunities in the area.
The average cost for a home in Bay Shore, NY is $516,528
The average cost for a 1 bedroom home in Bay Shore, NY is $390,250
The average cost for a 2 bedroom home in Bay Shore, NY is $385,964
The average cost for a 3 bedroom home in Bay Shore, NY is $498,137
Notice to Visitors
BankForeclosuresSale.com does not guarantee the availability of any property listed herein and does not promise that there are listings for every region.